When’s the last time your insurance company gave you the service and attention you deserve? At Plymouth Rock Assurance, we approach every call as an opportunity to leave you saying, “Wow!”
But don’t just take our word for it - year after year, we enjoy enviable service rankings as measured by the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance Annual Consumer Complaint Report. With fewer valid complaints than GEICO, Allstate, Liberty Mutual and State Farm, we are ranked among the best car insurance companies.
We didn’t establish our impressive reputation of excellent customer care by just simply meeting expectations. Get a better idea of how we go above and beyond:

Call 1.800.437.5556 if you bought insurance directly through Plymouth Rock, High Point Insurance, or from a Prudential Financial Professional.
Call 1.877.725.6423 if you bought insurance through a Plymouth Rock or Palisades Insurance independent insurance agent.
Call 1.866.658.3224 if you are a Teachers' Insurance Plan of NJ customer.
Not sure which number is right for you? Call us at 1.855.465.7722 and we'll get you to the right person.