Compare New Jersey Auto Insurance

When comparing New Jersey auto insurance you should consider the overall benefits of your policy, including your coverage options, your savings and your level of customer care.

Insurance is selling you a policy, but leaving you confused about what you just bought. That’s not us. At Plymouth Rock Assurance, you’ll see that assurance to us means an experienced, licensed insurance professional explaining your options so you know exactly what coverage you're buying from us and that it's right for you — plus it saves you money. You can rest assured that we’ll be there if you ever need us at a moment’s notice.

• Low-cost NJ car insurance rates in New Jersey
• All the features & benefits you deserve — for less
• #1 in New Jersey for customer care
• Over 94% claims satisfaction
• Plymouth Rock outranks the competition in survey of repair shops

Low Cost Car Insurance Rates in New Jersey 

We are passionate about saving our customers money. We carefully study competitors’ rates and find ways to beat them. Here’s how we compare to other car insurance companies.

The above annual average savings are based on customers who switched to High Point Auto Insurance from 11/09 - 2/11. Your premium may vary due to available discounts, eligibility requirements, driving record, and other factors. 

All the Features & Benefits You Deserve — For Less! 

	Plymouth Rock	State Farm	Allstate	GEICO
Rated #1 Customer Care in NJ
Door to Door Car Pickup/Delivery
24/7 Claims Reporting
Paid in Full Discount
New Car Replacement
Free iPhone App
Free Cab Ride Home

Certain restrictions, requirements and limitations apply to our free programs, policy features and discount offerings.

#1 in New Jersey for Customer Care 

Plymouth Rock continues to be #1 in customer care when compared to other auto insurance companies in New Jersey.

This is based on consistent ranking among the lowest valid complaints according to the 2010 Annual New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance Consumer Information Report, as well as High Point Auto Insurance and Palisades Insurance's unique, signature services such as Door to Door Valet Claim Service^SM, Pledge of Assurance^SM and customer feedback. Visit the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance Annual Consumer Information Report to see a full list of all New Jersey auto insurance company complaint records.

Over 94% Claims Satisfaction 

None of us intend on getting into an accident. If you have an accident, just know that we will be there for you and we have a track record you can count on.

We offer the below services to get you back on the road quickly in the event of an accident.

• Crashbusters^® - Plymouth Rock Crashbusters vans bring the claim settlement process right to the scene of the accident. We can even write a check on the spot in many cases. More information on Crashbusters.
• Door to Door Valet Claim Service^SM - We take the hassle out of the claims process when it comes to car repairs. If you get into an accident, we’ll pick up your car, get it repaired, and drop it back off to you. More information on Door to Door Valet Claim Service.

Plymouth Rock Outranks the Competition in Survey of Repair Shops 

 Not all insurance companies are the same when it comes to fixing your car. We outranked State Farm, GEICO and Progressive in a NJ survey of repair shops — see our stellar results below. At Plymouth Rock, we make sure the repairs to your car are top quality, that they're completed as quickly as possible with no unnecessary delays, and that the experience is easy for you.

Source: Surveys by USA/Direct, an independent research firm, December 2008 - January 2009 & March 2009. 

To compare New Jersey auto insurance rates, call us at 1.800.516.9242 or find an agent near you.

Read our important general disclaimer about auto insurance.